Skip to main content

Humanity as one piece

Japanese society appears to be very formal and they are known for their extremely polite manner of speech. However, if you have watched any shonen anime, you would notice the hero is nothing like that. The heroes generally speak in a very casual manner with no special reverence to anyone. This has always puzzled me. Firstly, how exactly do they pull it off? Secondly, how are the parents OK with showing such behaviour to teenage kids? As someone who received a lot of criticism during childhood for the way I behaved, I was always curious to know what is the secret towards being irreverent without being offensive. And I have always hoped I would find an answer in anime. And finally, I feel I have found a key to the answer in One piece.

Needless to say at this point that I would actually be talking about a certain episode of One Piece. I assure you that people who have not seen One piece would very well be able to follow this post. But, if you are afraid of spoilers, you should come back after watching the Zou Island arc in One Piece. I believe reading ahead would not kill your enjoyment of the arc, but I leave the decision up to you.

Momonosuke is one of the several kids rescued by Luffy (the hero) from Punk Hazard - an advanced lab where experiments were being conducted on children to make them giants. He, however, in his own words, is a very proud samurai. It is later revealed in Zou island that he is the current successor of Kozuki clan, the clan that made poneglyphs - giant stone tablets containing ancient forgotten history in an ancient forgotten language. It is further revealed that Momonosuke's father was killed by pirate Kaido, with whom Luffy also has some enmity. Momonosuke's retainers, people who were with Luffy's crew for quite some time, request Luffy's aid in avenging Pirate Kaido. To everyone's surprise, Luffy declines.

People watching it might not be that surprised by this reaction as Luffy's attention was fully fixed on the crying Momonosuke as the retainers were doing all this. In between when Nami (a crew member in Luffy's ship) walks ahead to comfort the crying Momonosuke, Luffy stops her with his hand. And it is indeed later made explicit that Luffy wants Momonosuke to ask him for his aid. He does not want Momonosuke to just be a decoration, but actually, take the lead of his people. The best scene is Luffy stopping Momonosuke as he is about to bow his head.

He agrees to form an alliance to defeat Kaide with Momonosuke an equal partner. As Kin'emon, one of Momonosuke's retainers points out "We were treating him as a kid, but he is the head of Kozuki clan. We were forgetting about that and thinking we have to protect him. Even though that was too harsh on an eight-year-old, no one treats Momonosuke-sama as a whole man as Luffy-dono does.". I guess if you can truly treat an 8-year-old your equal, then it is perfectly fine to treat an 80-year-old the same way. I feel that is what makes the heroes in anime special. They are effortlessly able to do this. Perhaps, people are able to see this and that is why they are not offended by the perceived irreverence from them. Mostly we get offended because we imply disrespect because we know this is not how he behaves with others. At the very least this is not how most people in the society behaves.

My favourite example to illustrate the social connotation behind implied disrespect is my personal experience when I was in France for a conference. It did not occur to say thank you when I was served food because no one does that in India. But, the person who served me the food was really offended because it is expected from in France. Another of my favourites would be the choice of pronouns one should use when speaking Indian languages. It is an extremely tricky terrain. Not being polite can offend people, but being too polite will sound formal and distant. Thankfully English got rid of thou.

Hierarchy comes in various forms. This is an example of one of the several forms. I think the way Luffy's crew treats him illustrate how lightly he carries his authority as a captain. This ability to treat everyone equally is a greater power than any Devil fruit or Haki (superpowers in one piece). I really wish to be able to treat everyone like that, and I am and will make the necessary efforts.

Behind this "surprising" reaction of Luffy is another nature of Luffy. Luffy is there to help even when his friends deny they need help. But, he does not make a major move until they explicitly ask for his help. In the Arlong arc when Nami falls into despair, she finally asks for help
Luffy was clearly waiting for this moment all along. He is there to help Nami all along but does not make any big move. And then comes one of my favourite scenes
He says nothing else. And there is no need to say anything else. It is well established by then that the hat is Luffy's one and only treasure. Handing that over to Nami says everything that needs to be said. Similarly, even when Robin says "All I want is to die", Luffy says "We have come all the way, so we will save you. If you still fill like dying, tell us then". But he does not make any move. He waits till Robin says the following
Oda Sensei makes his point clear by adding an earlier dialoge by Franky, incase someone had missed it
Even in Whole cake Island, it is the same. Sanji does his best to send Luffy away, but he does not go away. He stays there. But before he makes the big move, he wants Sanji to ask for it. Say clearly what he wants.
So, this adamance of wanting his friends to explicitly express what they want is indeed an important aspect of Luffy's character.


Popular posts from this blog

Naruto; the saddest death

For me, the saddest death in Naruto, is undoubtedly, Yashamaru's death. Let me say a few words about why I think so. For me death by itself is not sad. I would in fact say that death is a blessing for the one who is dying. It is sad for those who are left behind. From that perspective I think Yashamaru's death is the saddest. Yashamaru was the only comforting figure in the life of Gaara. The moment it is revealed that the assassin who tried to kill him was that same Yashamaru was heart breaking. The way Gaara cries "Yashamaru.." still resonates in my mind. Loneliness is one of the central themes of the anime. And, that scene captures it so magnificently. One of the most touching moments in the anime. There are several other deaths for which I shed a lot of tears. Like the deaths of Haku or Zabuza or Jiraiya or Obito. But they truly shine through their deaths. As Jiraiya himself says "The true measure of a shinobi is not how he lives but how h

Kumbalangi nights

I was not impressed by Kumbalangi nights.  I don't mean to say it is a bad film.  It is certainly worth watching.  The cinematography is extraordinary.  Also, it has its moments - nice little dialogues.  But with all that, it is just an average film, or so I feel.  As I had explained in a post before , people expect explanations when you express dislike.  Actually, I wouldn't say I dislike, but I did not like it as much as others - the people I talked to.  And, in this case, I think I understand some of the reasons.  And I will be sharing those reasons with you. What do you feel when you hear someone saying "These impoverished people are so lucky.  Wish I had a skinny body like them"?  Movies like Kumbalangi nights elicit the same emotion in me.  The major problem poor people face is lack of money.  If you make a movie on the poor and completely take money out of the equation, that makes no sense.  Kumbalangi nights does precisely that.  Not even once had they show

Android Kunjappan Ver 5.25

Android Kunjappan is a movie about loneliness at old age, but with many twists.  The movie is the story of Bhaskara Poduval and his loving son Subrahmanian (Chuppan).  Chuppan being educated and ambitious find it difficult to lead his life in rural Kerala.  Bhaskara Poduval, on the other hand, does not want to leave his home town.  Upon getting a lucrative job in a Japanese company, Chuppan leaves to Russia.  Initially, Chuppan appoints a couple of home nurses (one after the other) to take care of his father.  But, they all end up being comic disasters.  Finally, he brings a trial robot made by his company to take care of his father.  The rest of the movie is a story of companionship between man and machine.        Generally, in movies, the suffering of the elderly is caused by children who are complete jerks.  Such people certainly exist and it is worthwhile to portray their story.  However, it is important to realise, that often the elderly feel left out even under the care of wel